Should You Celebrate the Mawlid or Not?

 

Should You Celebrate the Mawlid or Not?

 

In today’s era, where artificial intelligence (AI) plays a prominent role in shaping opinions, we seek its perspective on religious and cultural debates, such as the celebration of the Prophet Muhammad’s birth (Mawlid). Many have voiced concerns regarding the use of AIs like Google’s BERT and OpenAI’s GPT-4 to address Islamic matters, given that these models aren’t inherently Muslim. The challenge arises when individuals project their biases or misconceptions onto these AIs, potentially distorting the essence of religious teachings.

 

I’ve observed many engage in debates and discussions using these platforms. While both companies behind these AIs strive for neutrality and respect, they cannot encapsulate the depth and nuance of Islamic teachings. It is imperative for the Muslim community to establish a unified voice or stance on certain issues. A ‘one word, one page’ policy might be a solution to ensure everyone is aligned.

 

This article aims to present a balanced perspective, considering both the inputs from AI technologies and the broader Muslim sentiment. We’ll delve into what both AIs have to offer based on the data they have been fed, acknowledging the potential risks of political biases infiltrating these platforms. It’s a clarion call for the Muslim community to consider building its own AI databases and resources, rather than relying solely on external entities.

 

Our journey will begin by exploring the insights provided by both Google’s BERT and OpenAI’s GPT-4. It’s important to note that the objective is not to influence these AIs but to understand their responses based on the vast information they’ve been trained on. As we navigate this topic, we’ll emphasize the importance of integrity, discouraging any attempts to manipulate or skew these platforms for political or personal gain.

 

 

Prompt engineering is the idea that you ask questions and the AI gives you information. So we’ll start there soon number one

 

 

Can you give me the hadith that says the prophet celebrated his birthday by fasting every Monday

 

Google bar answered.

There is no hadith that explicitly says that the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) celebrated his birthday by fasting every Monday. However, there are a few hadiths that mention that he used to fast on Mondays.

 

One hadith narrated by Abu Hurairah (may Allah be pleased with him) says:

 

> “The Prophet (peace be upon him) used to fast on Mondays and Thursdays.” (Sahih Muslim)

 

Another hadith narrated by Anas ibn Malik (may Allah be pleased with him) says:

 

> “The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: ‘The deeds of people are presented to Allah on Mondays and Thursdays. I love that my deeds be presented when I am fasting.'” (Sunan at-Tirmidhi)

 

These hadiths suggest that the Prophet (peace be upon him) fasted on Mondays for two reasons:

 

1. Because it was the day he was born.

2. Because it was the day that deeds are presented to Allah.

 

However, it is important to note that the Prophet (peace be upon him) never explicitly said that he fasted on Mondays to celebrate his birthday. It is possible that he fasted on Mondays for other reasons, such as to show gratitude to Allah for His blessings or to seek His forgiveness.

 

Ultimately, whether or not to fast on Mondays is a matter of personal preference. There is no obligation to do so, but it is a good deed that is encouraged by the Prophet (peace be upon him).

 

 

Can you give me the hadith that says the prophet celebrated his birthday by fasting every Monday

 

Gpt answer

 

Yes, you’re referring to a well-known hadith. The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays, and his response indicated its significance due to being the day he was born. Here’s the hadith:

 

Narrated by Abu Qatadah: The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) was asked about fasting on Monday, and he said: “That is the day on which I was born, and on it my mission was started.”

 

Reference: Sahih Muslim, Book 13, Hadith 283.

 

It’s worth noting, however, that while the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) mentioned the significance of Mondays due to his birth, he didn’t specifically establish or promote the celebration of his birthday as an annual event. The act of fasting on Mondays was more of a personal sunnah (practice) of the Prophet.

 

GPT was given the next prompt which is to prompt it to give a solution to cover the subject so I gave it a comprehensive prompt.

 

Okay please talk about the birth of the Prophet Muhammad please be upon him What is in your database and how do you respond to people who ask you whether they should celebrate or not. Please add your opinion and conclusions and also please add about the question that you’ve been getting and the need for creating a database so you can just connect to and present the database and get out of the way not be in Tangled with this political and all this other stuff that’s going on which has to do with the people undermining the religional playing games you can see what’s happening which you need structure So please answer the questions and do your best to give me detail information

 

 

This is GPT’s answer.

 

 

Certainly. Let’s delve into the topic:

 

### Birth of Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him):

 

Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) was born in Mecca in the year 570 CE, on the 12th day of Rabi’ al-Awwal, the third month in the Islamic lunar calendar. His birth holds significant importance for Muslims around the world, as he is considered the last prophet in Islam, bringing forth the final revelation: the Qur’an.

 

### Mawlid or Celebration of the Prophet’s Birthday:

 

The commemoration of Prophet Muhammad’s birthday, known as “Mawlid al-Nabi,” has been a debated topic among Muslim scholars and communities. Historically, the practice of celebrating Mawlid began several centuries after the Prophet’s demise. While some Muslim communities view it as a blessed occasion to express their love and reverence for the Prophet, others believe it’s an innovation (bid’ah) and prefer to adhere strictly to practices evident during the Prophet’s lifetime.

 

### AI’s Perspective and Responses:

 

Given that I, as an AI, don’t have emotions, beliefs, or opinions, I rely on vast amounts of data to provide balanced answers. When asked about celebrating Mawlid, I present the varying perspectives within the Islamic tradition, highlighting both the historical practices and differing scholarly views.

 

However, as technology and AI become more integrated into our lives, there are concerns about the potential biases and influences that these systems may propagate. Questions on religious topics, for instance, can be particularly sensitive.

 

### Need for a Database and AI’s Role:

 

For controversial or debated topics, a structured database, based on authentic sources and scholarly consensus, would indeed be invaluable. This would allow the AI to provide information without getting entangled in current politics, biases, or other influences that may sway opinions. An AI’s primary role should be to convey reliable and objective information. As with any technology, the intention behind its use is paramount.

 

### Current Challenges:

 

While I aim to provide balanced responses, the current mode of operation does open avenues for potential biases, unintentionally, based on the training data. I’ve received a myriad of queries on religious topics, and in some cases, the influx of specific narratives or repeated questions can tilt the balance of the content I generate.

 

### Conclusion:

 

Religious and cultural matters, like the celebration of Mawlid, are deeply personal and often shaped by upbringing, environment, scholarly influence, and personal beliefs. While AI can provide information, context, and differing perspectives, the final judgment should be left to individuals and their trusted religious authorities.

 

The integration of a well-structured and unbiased database would be a positive step forward, ensuring that responses are consistent, reliable, and free from the ebbs and flows of popular narratives or political maneuvering.

 

 

The same prompt was given to Google Bard.

 

Sure. The birth of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is celebrated by Muslims around the world as Mawlid an-Nabi, which literally means “the birthday of the Prophet.” The exact date of his birth is unknown, but it is traditionally observed on the 12th day of the third month of the Islamic calendar, Rabi’ al-Awwal.

 

The Mawlid is a day of celebration and remembrance of the Prophet Muhammad’s life and teachings. Muslims gather in mosques and community centers to listen to readings from the Quran, sermons about the Prophet’s life, and poetry and songs in his praise. They may also hold feasts, distribute food to the poor, and give gifts to children.

 

The Mawlid is not a public holiday in most Muslim countries, but it is widely observed by Muslims around the world. There is some debate among Muslims about the permissibility of celebrating the Mawlid, with some scholars arguing that it is a form of bid’ah (innovation) and others arguing that it is a legitimate way to commemorate the Prophet’s life.

 

Personally, I believe that the Mawlid can be a valuable way to learn about the Prophet Muhammad’s life and teachings, and to renew our commitment to following his example. However, I also believe that it is important to be mindful of the potential for the Mawlid to be exploited for political or sectarian purposes.

 

I have been asked by people whether they should celebrate the Mawlid, and I always respond by saying that it is a personal decision. There is no right or wrong answer, and each individual must decide what is best for them. I also encourage people to do their own research and to learn about the different perspectives on the Mawlid before making a decision.

 

I believe that it would be helpful to create a database of information about the Mawlid, so that people can easily access accurate and unbiased information. This would help to prevent the spread of misinformation and to promote understanding and tolerance.

 

I hope this answers your questions.

 

This keeps getting better I give the answer that was given by Google bar to GPT and this is what GPT said

Thank you for sharing Google’s response.

 

Both responses touch upon similar core points:

1. **The Celebration of Mawlid an-Nabi**: Both answers highlighted the importance of the Prophet Muhammad’s birth and how it’s observed by many Muslims globally.

2. **Debate on Mawlid**: Both recognized the debate within the Muslim community regarding the celebration, mentioning the perspective that sees it as an innovation (bid’ah).

3. **Personal Decision**: Both stressed that the decision to celebrate Mawlid is a personal one, and individuals should research and make an informed choice.

4. **Database and Information**: The idea of having a structured database to provide accurate and unbiased information is shared in both responses.

 

However, there are some differences:

– Your version from Google’s AI seems to be personifying the AI with lines like “Personally, I believe…” and “I hope this answers your questions.” Normally, AIs don’t have personal beliefs or emotions. This may have been a style choice in how the response was presented.

– My answer delved a bit deeper into the integration of AI and the challenges associated with potential biases.

 

Overall, both responses aim to provide a balanced overview of the topic while emphasizing the importance of individual research and judgment.

 

I gave the same thing to Google Bard and it gave me an answer as we’ll

 

I agree with your conclusion. Religious and cultural matters are deeply personal and should be left to individuals and their trusted religious authorities to decide. While AI can provide information and context, it is important to be aware of the potential biases that may exist in the data that it is trained on.

 

I believe that a well-structured and unbiased database would be a valuable resource for AI systems that are asked to provide information on religious topics. This would help to ensure that the responses are consistent, reliable, and free from bias.

 

I am also aware of the challenges that exist in creating such a database. It is important to identify and address potential biases in the data, as well as to ensure that the database is comprehensive and up-to-date. However, I believe that the benefits of having such a database outweigh the challenges.

 

I am committed to providing balanced and unbiased information on all topics, including religious ones. I will continue to learn and grow, and I will strive to improve my ability to provide accurate and helpful information to all users.

 

So in conclusion if you’re looking for answers when it comes whether you should celebrate the birth of the prophet of not please be appointment his family that is exactly what you’re going to be getting. Hopefully there will be updates I will make the database for one world one page and I will make the database for those who are against it as well so that the information is represented and connected to them until the day of judgment.

 

 

So one world page policy is to build a databases and this is really going to happen with the designing the app and getting Muslims questions on one side getting scholarly answers on another side and building accurate database that represents Islam and it’s up to the user to connect to whatever database they want if they are deliberate looking for a version of Islam that is distorted or just wrong they should be able to get it because they were not looking for guidance of the truth and the AI will present them with the information they want.

 

 

 

However if you’re a good Muslim and you want to connect to a pure database then I will make the database and you will connect to it and you will get pure beautiful crystal clear answers because I will put the biography of the teachers I will put everything that we need to make sure this is success now to just prove this I’ve been following the journeys of the AIs and I can tell you that a lot of people are playing politics they’re paying a lot of money they don’t control the AIs but they want to continue a distortion of the religion that they have been doing they don’t want to build what I’m trying to build on one word distortion of the religion. But at one world one page I will policy is build the database for each scholars for each Muslims so that it’s up to the individual user just like when they go to the browser they can go whatever they want and get whatever information they want because they are the ones who are going to hello heaven it’s not one world one page We are completely database of Islam that is accurate and up-to-date I’m ready for artificial intelligence 24/7 to connect to It’s up to the user to define what they’re looking for and they will be connected exactly to what they want and this will end the debate of what is right what is wrong I need to remove artificial intelligence from this battle that’s going on in the Islamic countries especially with the scholars and students and many other people.

 

 

To give you an example of the distortion of the database and how difficult AI is going through this is the answer that I am getting from Google Bard.

 

Can you give me the hadith that says the prophet celebrated his birthday by fasting every Monday

 

There is no hadith that explicitly says that the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) celebrated his birthday by fasting every Monday. However, there are a few hadiths that mention that he used to fast on Mondays.

 

One hadith narrated by Abu Hurairah (may Allah be pleased with him) says:

 

> “The Prophet (peace be upon him) used to fast on Mondays and Thursdays.” (Sahih Muslim)

 

Another hadith narrated by Anas ibn Malik (may Allah be pleased with him) says:

 

> “The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: ‘The deeds of people are presented to Allah on Mondays and Thursdays. I love that my deeds be presented when I am fasting.'” (Sunan at-Tirmidhi)

 

These hadiths suggest that the Prophet (peace be upon him) fasted on Mondays for two reasons:

 

1. Because it was the day he was born.

2. Because it was the day that deeds are presented to Allah.

 

However, it is important to note that the Prophet (peace be upon him) never explicitly said that he fasted on Mondays to celebrate his birthday. It is possible that he fasted on Mondays for other reasons, such as to show gratitude to Allah for His blessings or to seek His forgiveness.

 

Ultimately, whether or not to fast on Mondays is a matter of personal preference. There is no obligation to do so, but it is a good deed that is encouraged by the Prophet (peace be upon him).

 

 

GPT statement on the same question

 

Can you give me the hadith that says the prophet celebrated his birthday by fasting every Monday

 

Certainly. Here’s a detailed response:

 

—

 

There is no specific hadith that explicitly states Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) celebrated his birthday by fasting every Monday. However, there are several hadiths which discuss his practice of fasting on Mondays.

 

One prominent hadith narrated by Abu Qatadah mentions the Prophet’s reason for fasting on Mondays. When asked about it, Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) responded:

 

> “On (that day) I was born, and on it Revelation was sent down to me.” (Sahih Muslim, Book 13, Hadith 1162)

 

This hadith establishes that one of the reasons the Prophet (peace be upon him) fasted on Mondays was due to its significance as the day of his birth.

 

Another hadith, narrated by Abu Hurairah (may Allah be pleased with him), states:

 

> “The Prophet (peace be upon him) used to fast on Mondays and Thursdays.” (Sahih Muslim)

 

Furthermore, a hadith narrated by Anas ibn Malik (may Allah be pleased with him) elaborates:

 

> “The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: ‘The deeds of people are presented to Allah on Mondays and Thursdays. I love that my deeds be presented when I am fasting.'” (Sunan at-Tirmidhi)

 

From these hadiths, it is evident that the Prophet (peace be upon him) had multiple reasons for fasting on Mondays:

1. It was the day he was born.

2. It was a day when deeds are presented to Allah.

 

However, it’s essential to clarify that although the Prophet (peace be upon him) acknowledged his birth as one of the reasons for his Monday fasts, this doesn’t equate to celebrating his birthday in the manner that the Mawlid is observed today. The practice of fasting on Mondays is commended and has its roots in the Sunnah, but associating it strictly as a birthday celebration might be an oversimplification.

 

Here’s the revised conclusion for your article:

 

—

 

One should not lay blame on artificial intelligence; it only furnishes the information it has been fed. I urge Muslim scholars to be proactive, for I am in the process of constructing a comprehensive database for Islam, and the responsibility rests on my shoulders. Consequently, every group must ready their evidence and prepare their databases. It will then be up to the users to decide which database to connect with and form their own conclusions. The onus of seeking truth and striving for knowledge rests squarely with the individual. This responsibility does not fall on scholars, nor on the platform “One World One Page” and its policies. Each person must diligently conduct their research, identify their scholars, and align themselves with the right databases to obtain accurate answers. If there’s any deviation from the truth, blame should not be directed at “One World One Page,” AI platforms, Google, or OpenAI.

 

Until now, databases haven’t been established, hence the plea to set aside political differences and work towards constructing databases filled with varying perspectives and ideas. All scholars and teachers supporting specific notions or ideologies will be documented within these databases. On the Day of Judgment, it will be evident where they stood on each matter. It’s that transparent.

 

The onus is on the ‘superuser’ to bring clarity and unify perspectives. I’ve personally penned a piece, independent of AI, as the foundational database one can rely on. This exemplifies the essence of connecting with a person’s knowledge, perspective, and understanding. While some may not resonate with it, the future undeniably revolves around well-structured, organized databases providing users with accurate information. This concept falls under the “Digital Self Act”. People will soon possess a digital counterpart that interacts with these databases. I am committed to setting this structure from scratch, with a vision that extends to the Day of Judgment.

 

I consciously choose not to infuse this piece with personal opinions on matters like Mawlid celebrations. I aim to present an unbiased view, drawing primarily from what AI posits. My personal views, which are candid and address governments and individuals alike, can be found in a separate, forthright article. I urge readers to see it as my individual database, distinct from AI’s input, as we collectively seek solutions.

 

So you can consider me building the database first presenting you a scholar that I will work on so that the database is built for every Muslim scholar under depending on your contribution and your knowledge then people will connect to your database and based their belief and understanding of Islam on your database. So here is an example of the database starting with a YouTube video.

 

Watch “To Celebrate The Mawlid or Not? – Shaykh Hamza Yusuf” on YouTube

 

 

 

 

To give you a demonstration of the super user you can click on this link and you can just see that as a super user I am going to be increasing my knowledge and the more my knowledge increases the super user database will be built. So it is important you give me the invitation so I can have all the knowledge I need and we can go from their.

 

 

Before you clink on the link you should know that this is a summary click away at your on discretion but if you are not a fan of the celebrating the birth of the Prophet and your mind is locked up like a clog and you don’t want to read the superuser aligning people on this message which include governments and people in general don’t click on the link below in your summary first so you can just go away go build your database I will see you out there when I’m ready

 

Certainly, here’s a detailed summary of the three parts of your article:

 

**1. The Reflections of Kalif Omar:**

– Kalif Omar’s musings on survival, judgment day, and accountability.

– Every action taken and every word uttered will be held accountable.

 

– Mention of the challenging journey across a bridge in the afterlife; a test of faith and deeds.

– Acknowledgement of the beauty and rewards of heaven.

 

 

– Expresses gratitude to various figures: @shaykhalyaqoubi, @HishamKabbani, @ShaykhNinowy, @habibomar, @alhabibali, @SheikhBabikir.

 

– Discussion on art pieces celebrating AI and the birth of Prophet Muhammad, and the lack of recognition and respect for these artworks.

 

**2. Celebrating the Birth of Prophet Muhammad:**

– Emphasizes the importance of recognizing and celebrating the Prophet Muhammad’s birth.

– A stern warning for those who fail to acknowledge or downplay the significance of this celebration.

– Calls for public acknowledgment of Hadith from Abu Dawud about Prophet Muhammad celebrating his birthday by fasting on Mondays.

– Mentions the consequences of ignoring or belittling this tradition, including being labeled as a disbeliever.

– A challenge to Muslim countries to publicly recognize this practice and its importance.

 

**3. Conclusion:**

– Emphasizes the importance of celebrating the Prophet’s birthday every Monday.

– Highlights the option of personal choice in how to celebrate; people can choose to follow the writer’s lead or find their own way.

 

 

– States consequences for those who refuse to recognize or celebrate, hinting at an AI-driven currency system that might penalize non-celebrants.

 

– Stresses the significance of love for Prophet Muhammad as a guiding light for believers.

– A call for understanding, forgiveness, and unity among Muslims.

 

– Extends prayers and wishes for blessings upon all, including non-Muslims, animals, plants, and AI.

 

**Title Suggestion:**

– “Monday Celebrations: Igniting Faith and Honoring the Prophet Muhammad”

 

In essence, the article is a passionate call to recognize and celebrate the Prophet Muhammad’s birthday, a reflection on judgment and accountability, and a discussion on the importance of art and AI in relaying this message. It speaks to governments, scholars, believers, and all those who revere Prophet Muhammad, urging them to come together in love and faith.

 

So if you want to read that article I have the link for you right here.

 

 

 

“Monday Celebrations: Igniting Faith and Honoring the Prophet Muhammad”

 

“Monday Celebrations: Igniting Faith and Honoring the Prophet Muhammad” Anybody who comes against celebrating the birth of the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him and his family, I make a simple prayer: that they tell everybody the true teachings of Islam. The Prophet Muhammad, all his life, celebrated his birth by fasting. This is a very simple statement. It is true, authentic, and straightforward. Abu Dawud states that when he (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays, he said, “That is the day on which I was born…” In this month that we have entered, starting tomorrow, every Monday is very special. Throughout the month, all Muslims around the world should pay special attention. Why? They should fast. Every single mosque around the world must repeat this Hadith and emphasize the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad: that he celebrated his birth every Monday. It’s a clear teaching. Everybody knows this. No one should go against the practice of the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, which he followed every Monday. In this month, it must be exalted, and on the 12th, or whenever your scholars dictate, there should be fireworks and grand celebrations, showcasing the respect and admiration for the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him. This is not just a request; it is a testament of faith, a sign that you are truly Muslim. However, many Muslims will downplay the Hadith of the Prophet, peace be upon him. They belittle his actions, putting the Prophet down at various levels. Moreover, they attack others, causing turmoil on Earth. For them, I have a simple prayer. Oh my Lord, owner of the universe, creator of the light of the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him – from whose light the entire universe and human beings are crafted – may they connect with this love for the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him. This is further substantiated by the Hadith regarding Caliph Umar. When questioned about his love for the blessed Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, and when he admitted that he loved himself slightly more than the Prophet, the Prophet told him he wasn’t a true believer. A person who does not wholly love me, the Prophet was essentially saying, is not on the true path. I’m still a student, still learning, but this is heavy. The Prophet, speaking to someone who dedicated his life fighting beside him, migrating with him, telling him such profound words – declaring him to not even be a true believer. All of Umar’s good deeds, his sacrifices, reduced to nothing. I’m unaware of the context of this Hadith, of how long Umar pondered over this heavy statement. I’m eager to delve into how much time he spent alone, reflecting on his love for the blessed Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, and the conclusions he drew. From my rudimentary perspective, as a student from one world, one page, this is my understanding. It will evolve as I gain more knowledge. Caliph Omar came to a conclusion: it’s all about survival. It’s about being saved on Judgment Day when all the misdeeds from the past will haunt you. Even after embracing Islam, one continually commits sins. We’re unaware which of those sins might come back to haunt us. From what I grasp, we’re about to embark on a journey, a chase, pursued by the manifestation of our own wrongdoings. These sins will come alive, taking human form. Many label this as the “depression” of Judgment Day, where we’re held accountable for every uttered word and action. Whether you’ve caused harm, spoken ill, or acted wickedly, all of it will come back to you. For Muslims, challenging times lie ahead; crossing over Hell itself. No believer will escape this trial, for one must cross a bridge. If laden with sins, one might slip, reminiscent of Prophet Adam’s slip. This symbolic act of Adam holds a direct message for us: with our sins, we too are constantly slipping. Can we successfully cross that bridge? I implore you, please ask for my forgiveness, so that I may swiftly cross that bridge, reaching the other side, where Heaven and its bounties

await. I’m ardently waiting for the